top of page
Search

MCAT or Free Gingival Graft for a Thin Gingival Phenotype? 5 Take-Home Messages for Clinicians

Oct 23
2 min read

A thin gingival phenotype with a narrow band of keratinized tissue is common in the anterior mandible, and it often comes with gingival recession. Two well-established ways to change it are the modified coronally advanced tunnel (MCAT) and the free gingival graft (FGG). In our randomized controlled trial, published in Clinical Oral Investigations (2022), we compared the two head to head.

The study at a glance

  • 50 patients and 140 recession defects in the anterior mandible, all with thin gingiva and insufficient keratinized tissue

  • Randomized to MCAT or FGG and followed for 12 months

  • Clinical outcomes: gingival thickness, keratinized tissue height, recession depth and width, probing depth and clinical attachment level, measured at baseline, 6 weeks, 6 months and 12 months

  • Patient-based outcomes: wound healing, tissue appearance, patient expectations, aesthetics and dentin hypersensitivity, assessed at baseline and 6 months

Five take-home messages

1. Both techniques work. Every periodontal variable improved significantly from baseline to 12 months with both MCAT and FGG. Either is a valid way to modify a thin phenotype in the anterior mandible.

2. If your main goal is more keratinized tissue, FGG gives more. FGG produced the larger gain in keratinized tissue height. Even so, every MCAT site gained at least 2 mm of keratinized tissue by 12 months.

3. If you need thicker tissue and root coverage, MCAT does better. MCAT led to a greater increase in gingival thickness and greater root coverage than FGG.

4. Complete root coverage was similar. The rate of complete root coverage did not differ significantly between the two techniques.

5. Patients preferred MCAT. Wound healing, tissue appearance, meeting patient expectations and aesthetics all favored MCAT. Dentin hypersensitivity did not differ between groups.

Bottom line

Choose the technique by the goal. When thickness, root coverage and aesthetics matter most, MCAT is the better fit. When the priority is the widest possible band of keratinized tissue, FGG remains the more predictable option.

Reference

Yilmaz BT, Comerdov E, Kutuk C, Nart J, Keceli HG. Modified coronally advanced tunnel versus epithelialized free gingival graft technique in gingival phenotype modification: a comparative randomized controlled clinical trial. Clinical Oral Investigations. 2022;26(10):6283–6293. doi:10.1007/s00784-022-04580-0. ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT04690140.

This summary is written for dental professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgment.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page